Top 5 Bloody Marys To Try In Waukesha

Bloody Mary’s aren’t just a drink to consume during brunch, as far as anyone in Wisconsin in concerned! Bloody Mary’s are a socially acceptable drink to have morning, afternoon, or even as a nightcap. Take a peek at the top 5 Bloody Mary’s to try in Waukesha! Why take my advice, you ask? Because I’m an expert, just ask me.

For those not from Wisconsin, when I list garnishes, it is basically all the extras you get with your drink!

 1. Soblemans 

I promise you under all of that food is an actual drink. I don’t know how the bartenders do it, but they are able to make magic out of the way they put their Bloody Mary’s together! I wonder if they have to get certified in “defying the law of gravity Ph.D.” in order to work here?!

While this would have been reserved for my top Bloody Mary list in Milwaukee, it does have a location in Waukesha, so it just had to be included! You think Bloody Mary in Wisconsin, and you automatically think Soblemans. Everything tastes exceptional from the bloody mix to the fixings and garnishes! It is a bit of a thicker mix, and they take the time to infuse and use all the right spices one could ever want in their drink.

If you are not from Wisconsin, this is the place you want to come to truly experience the myth, the legend and the magic that is known as the true Wisconsin Bloody Mary.

They have eight different types of Bloody Marys that escalate in girth as you go down the list. To be honest, the core of the Bloody itself tastes delicious on its own, and you don’t rely whatsoever on the toppings to give the drink the recognition it deserves!

Getting a Bloody from here is a meal in itself, and you don’t need much more! You get a drink and a meal all on top of one glass. The mix is on the bit of the thicker side, which I love.

Classic garnishes include:

  • Celery
  • Pickle
  • Green Olives
  • Tomato
  • Cheese Block
  • Beef Stick
  • Shrimp
  • Pickled Brussel Sprout
  • Pickled Mushroom
  • Green Onion
  • Pickled Asparagus
  • Pepperoncini

From there additional things can get added such as:

  • A Cheeseburger Slider
  • Bacon-Wrapped Chicken with Bourbon Sauce or Buffalo Sauce
  • Bacon-Wrapped Jalapeno Cheese Balls
  • A Whole Fried Chicken
  • Bacon Cheese Cracks
  • Coronita

 

Does It Come With A Beer Chaser: DUH

Restaurant Info:

332 Williams St,
Waukesha, WI 53186
Phone (262) 408-2320
Mon-Sat: 11 am – 11 pm (Grill closes at 10 pm)
Sun: 11 am – 9 pm*
*Closing hours are flexible, please call (262) 408-2320 to check times.

Yelp Stats

4.5 out of 75 reviews

Food Options

The Bloody Mary and all the fixings should be enough to fill you up, but if you really want to try other items here they are known worldwide for their burgers! They also have other standard bar food far, and I enjoy the cheese balls; they are different than your classic cheese curds!

Reviewers Have Said:

  • Bloody Mary drinks are large, delicious and a full meal. I ordered one with a slider and three apps, plus garnishes that included shrimp and cheese and sausage. The sidecar beer was excellent and from a local brewery across the street
  • Not only does the Bloody Mary have amazing toppings but it is actually delicious! It was spiced with a great depth of flavor!
  • Of all the bars in Wisconsin, Sobelman’s has the best Bloody Mary’s by far.

2. Taylor’s People Park 

I’m going to be honest with you, Taylor’s People Park has a good bloody, but it’s not my favorite. I’m not a fan of their actual Bloody Mary mix due to the nature of it being a bit thinner and toned down on the flavor spectrum.

However, I realize I’m a bit of a spice fanatic, so if you are one who likes a thinner, more light and refreshing bloody, then you will love them here! Great for those who don’t like spicy Bloody Marys and also those who want more bland choices; due to personal preference or you medically need to watch your sodium intake. When you take the refreshing Bloody Mary and mix that with the restaurant’s ambiance, specifically the outside rooftop patio, that is what lands this on my must-try Bloody Mary list.

Garnish include:

  • Beef Stick
  • Cheese Cube 1 Chedder and 1 Pepperjack
  • Lime Wedge
  • Olive
  • Pickle

The garnishes seem to be a bit inconsistent when I come here. Sometimes it’s all olives, sometimes there’s a fat pepper on it, etc. Its sort of like roulette which makes it fun. A few different Bloody Mary Drinks are available for you to choose from.

Does It Come With A Beer Chaser: Yes Sir!

Restaurant Info 

337 W. Main St. Waukesha, WI 53186

Open Weekdays at 11 am and Saturday and Sunday at 10 am for weekend brunch.
Serving food until 11 pm Sunday through Thursday and until 1 am on Friday and Saturday.

262.522.6868

They have outside seating on the sidewalk, but the real show stopper is their rooftop patio bar that has a full tiki-style theme going on. It is entirely open, so all you see when you look up is the sky, and when you look to the side you get an impressive view of the city of downtown Waukesha!

Yelp Stats

4 star out of 244 reviews

Food Options  

The food here is AMAZING. I personally always go for an appetizer buffet type of meal and get tons of apps to share around vs. getting an entree. My go-to apps are KYOTO Wings, Crab Rangoon Spring Rolls, Brushetta, and Pot Stickers.
They have food options for everyone; healthy, vegetarian, and even cheat meal dishes. You can find things like chicken sandwiches, burgers, sweet potatoes, fries, salads, fish, soups, grilled portobello sandwich, and so much more!

Reviewers Have Said:

  • I had the bourbon bloody and friend had the basil bloody. The basil was pretty good but not great. Overpowered with garlic and I love garlic. The bourbon bloody was almost undrinkable. Tomato and bourbon it seems is not a good combo lol.
  • We ordered bloody mary’s which were great and I love when a place gets it right and serves it will a beer back.
  • Each one of these additions[ garnishes] was more delicious than the last, which helped distract me from an otherwise average Bloody Mary mix.
  • We love the bloody many selections and the staff is always nice

3. Fuzzy’s Sports Pub & Grill

Fuzzy’s is the hole in the wall dive bar that has an exceptional Bloody Mary. They have their very own mix and give you full-sized garnishes! This mix is a perfect blend of thin and thick, making it desirable for everyone’s palette. On Sundays, they offer $3 Bloody Marys which is 75% cheaper than anywhere else in Wisconsin! Yea you read that correct, $3!

They also have a beautiful outside patio which is great for sipping your Bloody Mary on! When you mix the atmosphere with the Bloody Mary the two encompass everything sconnies love about hometown bars!

Garnish Include:

  • Pickle
  • Celery
  • Olive
  • Cheese
  • Beef Stick
  • Mushroom
  • Cucumber
  • Pepperoncini
  • Lemon Wedge

The garnish might be different depending on the day you come and the kind you choose.

Does It Come With A Beer Chaser: Yes, you get to choose the type of beer!

Restaurant Info

627 E Main St, Waukesha, WI 53186

(262) 524-8899

Mon – Wed 8 AM – 2 AM

Thur – Fri 6 AM – 2 AM

Sat – Sun 7 AM – 2 AM

Yelp Stats

4 stars out of 72 reviews

Food Options 

Fuzzy’s is your classic bar food but made in a non-greasy way, and they serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Reviewers Have Said:

  • Delicious food, great Bloody Mary, very friendly waitstaff- will come back
  • My favorite things are breakfast, the burgers are one of the best around and their Bloody Mary’s
  • had to get one of the $3  bloody mary’s that comes with a beer chaser of your choice.
  • had a Bloody Mary and a mimosa, and both were great.

4. Mainstream Bar & Grill 

Mainstream is another Bloody Mary place that is great for people who don’t like their mix to have to much spice but still want exceptional flavor. The density of the mix is medium and goes down smooth; before you know it you will have two knocked back. The restaurant has a relaxed rock and roll vibe to it and has a lovely deck outside in the back of their establishment.

Garnish Include:

  • Olive
  • Pickle
  • Celery
  • Lemon Wedge

The garnishes aren’t as over the top as some of the other places we have gone over. Sometimes a simplistic classic recipe has all the ingredients your heart and tummy can desire. It’s not about the over the top presentation, but rather the hard work and care that goes into making an uncomplicated, classic cocktail.

Does It Come With A Beer Chaser: Yes, again, we’re in Wisconsin

Restaurant Info

404 W Main St, Waukesha, WI 53186

(262) 544-6222

Mon – Thur 4 PM – 2 AM

Fri – Sat 11 AM – 2:30 AM

Sun 11 AM – 2 AM

Yelp Stats 

4.5 stars out of 138 reviews

Food Options 

This place is known around town for their bomb a$$ food! They have top-notch wings, burgers, loaded tots, fish fry, flatbreads, chips, cheese curds, and so much more! Great to come at any time of the day and is a real neighborhood hot spot to eat some exceptional food. You will come in a stranger and leave with some new acquaintances, they are very welcoming to everyone and anyone here!

Reviewers Have Said:

  • Grab a Bloody Mary. A Breakfast Burger, and Loaded Tots.
  • talk about a friendly/helpful waitress our waitress helped me two weeks in a row on how to add a photo to my post… TOP NOTCH HELP!!!
  • Drinks we’re good as well. Service fast and courteous. I liked the place and will be back to try their burgers.

5.The Neighbors Bar and Grille

The neighbors live up to its name and indeed treats you like a neighbor as soon as you walk in. You can go there for the first time, and the friendly vibe of the place instantly surrounds you, making you think you’ve actually been there before. Belly up to the bar, grab a seat at a table or go outside on their awesome deck style patio. A bar named

The Neighbors has a deck for their patio, does it get anymore Wisconsin than that?
The mix to their Bloodies is medium to thick in its consistency, and has one of my favorite tastes with all the spices and garnishes they add!

Waiters and bartenders are hands down my favorite staff around the area and I try to go here monthly just to see them, eat some good food and sip on some good drinks.

Garnishes Include:

  • Lemon Wedge
  • Cucumber
  • Mushroom
  • Olive
  • Pickle
  • Celery
  • Shallot
  • Beef Stick
  • Green Onion
  • Cheese

Does It Include A Beer Chasser: Yes!

Restaurant Info:

S16 W22255 Arcadian Ave, Waukesha, WI 53186

(262) 408-5872

Mon 10:30 AM – 12 AM

Tue – Thur 10:30 AM – 2 AM

Fri & Sat 10:30 AM – 2:30 AM

Sun 10:30 AM – 12 AM

Yelp Stats 

4 stars out of 45 reviews

Food Options 

This place has high-quality bar food with things like burgers, sandwiches, fries, tots, wings, pretzel bits, nutty jalapeno and much more! This place is known for its food and is a real hidden gem.

Reviewers Have Said:

  • The Bloody Mary was outstanding!  It even had a Wisconsin Beefstick! Nowhere in this country, can you find sausage as you get here!
  • I also tried the Bloody Mary which was fresh and well made. The prices are reasonable and it’s easy to get a table for lunch.
  • They have the best tasting Bloody Mary out there!! They have a mild and wild flavor and it comes with the most AMAZING jalapeño and cheddar beef stick and delicious blue cheese stuffed olives.  It is also packed with other goodies such as mushrooms, onion, celery, etc. we used to go there on the weekends for brunch and their food is also very good.
  • This place also makes one of the best Bloody Mary’s in the Waukesha area (technically the town) ’cause I like ’em spicy! (They can do half and half of their mix for you weak links out there!)

Enjoyed this read? Check out these related articles!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like